idnes
Ten článek na idnes je uplně mimo...nevim nevim...ale podle toho co sem četl...tak tomu Spáčilová asi ,,hodně rozumí"...
|
reagovat
|
Diskuze k článku Silent Hill: Recenze
příspěvky 321 - 340
Napsat příspěvek
- 1
- 2
- .
- 16
- 17
- 18
- .
- 21
- 22
je tam spousta chyb a nepřesností... např. to chtělo studio aby byla do filmu připsána můžská postava. A zase se tam objevuje teorie že jen děti hrají hry a že filmy podle her jsou stupidní akční sračky. mimochodem Radha Mitchell se k reakcím kritiky vyjídřila více než trefně...link . A taky není pravda že nebyly projekce pro tisk... ty byly už 18. a silent hill měl premiéru tuším 22 :). Mimochodem Ebert už má skoro 70. a jeho kritiky jsou obzvláště "vtipné", proto mne potěšil Gans a jeho "F*ck Ebert!" ještě při postprodukci filmu 
|
reagovat
|
V recenzii na Tokyo Drift s imfom suhlasim, ale tu tomu dal prilis mnoho hviezdiciek. Skuste si zahrat akykolvek Silent Hill a bude to lepsi zazitok nez pozriet si film. Cakal som predsa len nieco viac
|
reagovat
|
Luki
Pekne a pravdive.. obzvlast ten koniec je na ... blasting Samael into bits..
... blasting Samael into bits..|
reagovat
|
No jelikož tady odstavce nejsou začněte na řádku "of it" druhý pod mou ikonkou :)
|
reagovat
|
Pro fanoušky hry a halvně prvního dílu tohle byste si měli přečíst předtím než film uvidíte, je to názor ke kterému se připojuji.... pokud jste hru nedohráli tak přeskočtě první odstavec....
My point exactly. I think people tend to completely ignore the value of the new things provided by the movie because they just refuse to let go of the value of the old. The entire point about how it was more tragic that Alessa was hiding from Dahlia than taking revenge of the cult reeked of it, I honestly don't see how the way the movie handled it is in any way less valid or less poignant than what the game showed; again simple lack of acceptance that this is not the same Alessa as in the game; this is not the same story as in the game, so of course it MUST be bad.
I thought the movie was great and the fact that I went in knowing it wasn't going to tell me the same story as the game really did wonders, because I never once found myself in that old fan-elitistic point of view of "why did they change this? how could they do this differently? they're betraying that character's raison d'etre! This movie sucks!" Which is the main reason some fans are disliking it.
The public and critic response I expected, in the sense that I knew people would simply not get it, and would most definitely never take it as seriously as we take the games, so that in particular doesn't bother me. But it bothers me when fans say things like "Alessa wasn't like that in the game!" well...the movie was never supposed to show Alessa exactly like that, I thought that much was clear since MONTHS before the movie came out, then it actually happened and everybody acts like they're shocked she was different.
This being a topic about Gans, I feel I need to say the main reason this elitistic point of view angers me is that seeing how impossible it is to satisfy us, Gans might just say "screw it, they can all go to hell" then we'd get some stupid hack directing part two and get Milla Jovovich air-kicking the ass out a demon which they'll ACTUALLY call Samael, then blasting it to bits with a rocket launcher. THEN I guess, we'd be happy with the SH movie we got.
My point exactly. I think people tend to completely ignore the value of the new things provided by the movie because they just refuse to let go of the value of the old. The entire point about how it was more tragic that Alessa was hiding from Dahlia than taking revenge of the cult reeked of it, I honestly don't see how the way the movie handled it is in any way less valid or less poignant than what the game showed; again simple lack of acceptance that this is not the same Alessa as in the game; this is not the same story as in the game, so of course it MUST be bad.
I thought the movie was great and the fact that I went in knowing it wasn't going to tell me the same story as the game really did wonders, because I never once found myself in that old fan-elitistic point of view of "why did they change this? how could they do this differently? they're betraying that character's raison d'etre! This movie sucks!" Which is the main reason some fans are disliking it.
The public and critic response I expected, in the sense that I knew people would simply not get it, and would most definitely never take it as seriously as we take the games, so that in particular doesn't bother me. But it bothers me when fans say things like "Alessa wasn't like that in the game!" well...the movie was never supposed to show Alessa exactly like that, I thought that much was clear since MONTHS before the movie came out, then it actually happened and everybody acts like they're shocked she was different.
This being a topic about Gans, I feel I need to say the main reason this elitistic point of view angers me is that seeing how impossible it is to satisfy us, Gans might just say "screw it, they can all go to hell" then we'd get some stupid hack directing part two and get Milla Jovovich air-kicking the ass out a demon which they'll ACTUALLY call Samael, then blasting it to bits with a rocket launcher. THEN I guess, we'd be happy with the SH movie we got.
|
reagovat
|
Jo, to je pravda. Docela by me zajimalo, jak by to vypadalo, kdyby nevysel Saw. Ten to podle mne zacal..
|
reagovat
|
Xatrix: Já jsem šťastnej že už se i hororům u nás začíná trošku více někdo věnovat... když zpomenu na ty otřesné chudé cz stránky na House of Wax a The Ring TwO 
|
reagovat
|
2Luki: No na muj vkus je to docela prehypovany - jako kdyby slo o nejvetsi krvak stoleti. Ale aspon neco.. 
|
reagovat
|
Luki
:) dobra je veta z popisu filmu : "Silent Hill režíruje Christophe Gans, zodpovědný třeba za Bratrstvo vlků, jehož atmosféra se dala krájet snad jen motorovou pilou."
|
reagovat
|
Dik, moc se na to tesim ( tak doufam ze me to nezklame ) a rad bych o tom vedel co nejmin. Na ten film se tesim uz hezkou radku mesicu ( kdyz jsem videl release datum u nas malem sem dostal infarkt ). Tenhle tyden bude fakt k nevydrzeni. Jeste ze mam zkousky
|
reagovat
|
Xatrix@ ale to není spoiler :D je to scéna skoro na začátku filmu :)) Ale chápu, co nejmíň informací :D
|
reagovat
|
imf@ na jakou adresu mám poslat květiny? Jinak jsem se tě chtěl zeptat co si myslíš o "mňau mňau" scéně?
Jinak jsem se tě chtěl zeptat co si myslíš o "mňau mňau" scéně? |
reagovat
|
No, tak ze bych se preci jenom s tou reklamou mylil? V tomhle pripade to bude jen dobre..
|
reagovat
|
TOP Diskuze
101Gladiátor 2: Recenze 131Casting na Bonda začal, producenti hledají třicátníky 26Jak vycvičit draka: Teaser 26Víkendový výplach #794 o Pánovi prstenů a Deadpoolovi 24Nový Predátor se blíží. A slibuje hodně zajímavého hrdinu 19Předražené Red One s Rockem prodělá miliardy korun. Gladiátor 2 se rozjel ve světě 19Kevin Smith chystá druhé Dogma 17První reakce: Čarodějka je magickou podívanou, hlásí naprosto nadšené recenze 14Nejhorší obavy: V.I.M. 13Minecraft film: Trailer
Komentáře
teď bych si ještě přál abyste konečně udělali knížku o těch 50 filmech před Star Wars 